Analog.com Analog Dialogue Wiki 简体中文
EngineerZone
EngineerZone
  • Log In
  • Site
  • Search
  • User
  • Support

    Popular Forums

    • RF and Microwave
    • Power Management
    • Video
    • FPGA Reference Designs
    • Precision ADCs
    • Linux Software Drivers
    • SigmaDSP Processors & SigmaStudio Dev. Tool

    Product Forums

    • A2B
    • Amplifiers
    • Analog Microcontrollers
    • Clock and Timing
    • Data Converters
    • Direct Digital Synthesis (DDS)
    • Energy Monitoring and Metering
    • Interface and Isolation
    • MEMS Inertial Sensors
    • Processors and DSP
    • Switches/Multiplexers
    • Temperature Sensors
    • Voltage References
    View All

    Application Forums

    • Audio
    • Automated Test Equipment (ATE)
    • Condition-Based Monitoring
    • Depth, Perception & Ranging Technologies
    • Embedded Vision Sensing Library
    • Motor Control Hardware Platforms
    • Optical Sensing
    • Precision Technology Signal Chains Library
    • Video
    • Wireless Sensor Networks Reference Library

    Design Center Forums

    • ACE Evaluation Software
    • ADEF System Platforms
    • Design Tools and Calculators
    • FPGA Reference Designs
    • Linux Software Drivers
    • Microcontroller no-OS Drivers
    • Reference Designs
    • Signal Chain Power (SCP)
    • Software Interface Tools
    • System Demonstration Platform (SDP) Support
  • Learn

    Highlighted Webinar

    Multidimensional Simulations of Beamformers and other RF Integrated Circuits in Keysight SystemVue

    Recent Discussions

    • Issue running built programs on Pluto
    • Activity: Simple Op Amps, For ADALM1000 Fig. 1.3 Buffering example
    • ADALM-PLUTO [NETWORK] vs [USB_ETHERNET]
    • Using buffer size different from 2**n
    • ADALM1000 Pixelpulse feature Source Voltage / Measure Current explanation

    Places

    • ADI Education Home
    • ADI Education China
    • ADI Education India
    • ADI Education Philippines
    • StudentZone (Analog Dialogue)
    • Virtual Classroom

    Latest Webinars

    • Multidimensional Simulations of Beamformers and other RF Integrated Circuits in Keysight SystemVue
    • Improve Smart Building Energy Efficiency with Industrial Ethernet Controlled Air Conditioning (HVAC) Systems
    • Sustainable Motion Control Solutions for High Performance Servo Drives
    • Audio Design Solutions for Augmented and Virtual Reality (AR/VR) Glasses
    • Robust Industrial Motor Encoder Signal Chain Solutions
    View All Webinars
  • Community Hub

    Challenge Yourself!

      KCC's quizzes AQQ235 about a bipolar common emitter amplifier - a kind proposal from our colleague Martin Walker
    View All

    Places

    • Community Help
    • Logic Lounge

    Resources

    • EZ Code of Conduct
    • Getting Started Guide
    • ADI: Words Matter
    • Community Help Videos
    View All
  • Blogs

    Highlighted Blogs

    Crawl, Walk, And Run - The Journey To Create The Phaser

     

    Hardware Holds The Key To Making Industrial Systems IEC 62443 Compliant

    Latest Blogs

    • Behind the Scenes of DIYRadio Blogs: An Introduction
    • Empowering Surveillance Cameras To Capture A Scene Without Being Heard
    • Mastering The Metrics Makes Specifying Encoders Simpler
    • Understanding Secret Key Cryptography Without Formulas
    • 3 Reasons Why IO-Link is Changing Smart Factory Decision Making
    Read All Blogs

    ADI Blogs

    • EZ Spotlight
    • The Engineering Mind
  • Partners

    Electronic Design Services - PartnerZone

    • Boston Engineering
    • Calian, Advanced Technologies
    • Colorado Engineering Inc. (DBA CAES AT&E)
    • Clockworks Signal Processing
    • Epiq Solutions
    • Fidus
    • PalmSens
    • Richardson RFPD
    • Tri-Star Design, Inc.
    • VadaTech
    • Vanteon
    • X-Microwave
    View All
ADIsimPE Library
  • Power Management
ADIsimPE Library
Documents ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results
  • Members
  • Tags
  • More
  • Cancel
  • Documents
  • 2015080- Anveshan 2014
  • AD539 Spice model
  • AD633 noise SImetrix model doesn't match datasheet
  • AD633 using ADIsimPE
  • AD8000 model
  • AD8227 does not work well on LTSpice
  • AD8336 spice model is not working
  • AD8336 with ADISimPE
  • AD8338 in PSPice
  • ADA2200 Encrypted Model
  • ADA2200 Spice Model
  • ADA4941-1 .cir
  • ADIsimPE 8.0 does not install - install shield stops at 20% and then does not respond.
  • ADIsimPE Design Tool model for ADP3050
  • ADIsimPE fails to update
  • ADIsimPE Full license version
  • ADIsimPE How do I check the number of node
  • ADIsimPE How do I define the correct symbol?
  • ADIsimPE How to use diffrential amp?
  • ADIsimPE License Issues
  • ADIsimPE Sallen key low pass filter Bode plot
  • ADIsimPE schematic from UG-241
  • ADIsimPE support Community
  • ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results
  • ADP7142 Spice Model
  • ADP7183 Adjustable Voltage
  • AMP Noise Analysis
  • An error message appeared and said " *** ERROR *** The circuit is too large to simulate with this version. Too many analog nodes" .
  • Analogous mechaniocal electrical system- LTSPICE
  • Announcing the release of ADIsimPE 8.0
  • Bode plot in SimPE
  • Can an isolated DC/DC converter be created in ADIsimPower?
  • Can I import PSPICE models into ADIsimPE?
  • can not open model
  • Can you provide the non-linear model for HMC441LM1 power amplifier. I noticed that it is available in ADISimRF, but I wanted to incorporate it in my ADS simulations.
  • Can't find Comparator AD790 in ADIsimPE Library
  • Can't update ADIsimPE...?
  • CN0337 in ADIsimPE
  • Components not found in the new 7.20 ADIsimPE version
  • Could I have AD8250 model file?
  • Creating Spice model from time-domain oscilloscope data
  • DDS driven PLL ADIsimpll
  • different result's between ADIsimPE and Diff Amp Calculator!!!
  • encrypted models for amplifiers
  • Encrypted SPICE AD797 and AD734
  • excel 2007 crashing
  • high speed pulses with AD8009an in ADIsimPE
  • HMC477 and HMC733 library
  • HMC807 EVB schematic bug
  • How can to fix netlist after changing symbol pin order?
  • How do i link the Anlog Devices supplied AD630.cir file into my schematic/simulation using ADIsimPE
  • how to add LT6011 spice model to ADIsimPE?
  • How to add part to the library folder of ADIsimPE simulator?
  • How to avoid erasing old curves
  • How to emulate T/I design bench?
  • How to export ASCII text of simulated curve
  • How to simulate PD signal?
  • How to simulate signal?
  • How to use ADIsimPower with ADisimPE integration
  • I need to get 5V DC from an analogue telephone line without looping the line.
  • I replaced a single opamp with a ADA4700. This resulted in an*** ERROR *** The circuit is too large to simulate with this version. Too many analog nodes. Why?
  • I want to simulate with AD9833. For that i need SPICE model (library file) of AD9833. So please let me know where do I get it or is there any simulation software for that?. Thank you
  • I want to simulate with ADR3540.
  • In trouble simulating IN-AMP
  • Installed ADIsimPI right now and at first start it says that it only have 14 days remaining
  • Is it possible to simulate a battery in ADIsimPE?
  • Is there a license expiration period for ADIsimPE ???
  • Is there a LT3032 model available for ADIsimPE ?
  • Is there a way to integrate and simulate ADP5090 Model(SIMPLIS) and AD8210(SiMetrix) into a single circuit?
  • Is there a way to simulate the ADuM2250 in ADIsimPE ? It only appears to have an IBIS model.
  • Is there any difference between ADIsimPE and Pspice model?
  • Is there any way to fully simulate the ADP5054 with Buck 1 and Buck 2 in parallel?
  • Linear regulator models?
  • looking for some photo diode model
  • NEW DSP
  • Noise analysis
  • Noise analysis ADIsimPE
  • Noise analysis of ADIsimPE
  • Phase angle measurement
  • problem simulating AD736 in ADIsimPE
  • Program expired
  • PSpice model
  • Quick Start user Guide - UG706
  • Regarding ADP5301
  • Simulate with an AMP03, Importing Models
  • Simulation using AD8336, AD736 and AD8551 spice models in Pspice
  • Solution for ADIsimPE Update Error
  • Too many analog nodes in ADISIMPE Simulation
  • troubles with SPICE models of AD8033 and AD8065
  • Use LTspice .sub model in ADIsimPE
  • waht analog devices equpment i can apply for design capacitive humidity sensor with 0..10V analog output signal
  • What is ADIsimPE?
  • When I run efficiency on simulator...
  • Where can I post LTSpice questions?
  • Where do I find an ADIsimPE tutorial

ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results

Original Question: ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results by EVC

I have ran the Design Tool and exported the Bode+LoadTransient+Ripple file for simulation in ADISimPE. I started with the configuration of the first figure below for sanity check (I ultimately want to simulate the circuit with a LC filter for minimum ripple). I am getting some funny results with the bode simulation.

Bode plot in the Design Tool:

ADISimPE bode plot:

It reports a nearly 0 gain margin and -158° phase margin and that may explain the oscillation in the transient simulation graph:

I am attaching the ADISimPE file created by DT that generated the two graphs above. What am I missing?

Thank you in advance for the support.

PS: I am hope I am posting in the right place, ADIsimPE appears with a "Power By Linear" that implies Linear Technology solutions though the particular IC I am using is AD.

ADP2384_Buck_B_LT_R.wxsch.zip

Verified Answer: RE: ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results by ezadminThis question has been assumed as answered either offline via email or with a multi-part answer. This question has now been closed out. If you have an inquiry related to this topic please post a new question in the applicable product forum.

Thank you,
EZ Admin
Question: RE: ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results by EVC

Hello, no clue about this issue? I would love to design with this IC but I would feel more comfortable having some trustworthy simulation results to back it up.


Question: RE: ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results by Ryang

Hello Sir,

According to your design spec of output ripple, it is required that the ripple value is smaller than 5mV. So a second LC filter is needed to suppress the ripple.

If a second LC is used and the feedback point is directly from Vout only using a resistor divider, then the loop may have stability issue. we recommend to add another cap (~10nF) between the first LC output point and FB pin. That will help to stable the loop.

Thanks!


Question: RE: ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results by EVC

Hi

Thank you for your response.

It does not address my concerns though. The SIMPLIS file was exported by the excel spreadsheet. I tried a more conservative design, with 2% ripple but the circuit exported to SIMPLIS is still unstable.

So the question is still which result should I rely on, the spreadsheet's or SIMPLIS's?


Suggested Answer: RE: ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results by Ryang

Hi,

I noticed that the Simplis schematic file exported from the excel tool has an extra Cff (1nF) which is not needed in the design.

When removing the Cff and run the simulation file again, you will get the result as below:

The regulator is stable. Basically, you can trust both excel and simplis simulation result. Just make sure the simplis schematic matches with the excel settings.

Thanks!


Suggested Answer: RE: ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results by Ryang

Here is the picture files, not sure why they are not shown on the previous reply.


Question: RE: ADP2384 Design Tool vs ADISimPE results by EVC

Hello, Ryan.

Thanks for the heads up.

I noticed the capacitor but forgot to eliminate it from the schematics. It is stable but results do not match: compare crossover frequency, gain and phase margins and the graphs themselves. I suppose SIMPLIS's results are more trustworthy. 

I suggest the tools undergo a review. The IC looks to be very good but the tool needs improvement. I wonder if one can trust the thermal performance data.

Best Regards.

  • Share
  • History
  • More
  • Cancel
Related
Recommended
Social
Quick Links
  • About ADI
  • ADI Signals+
  • Analog Dialogue
  • Careers
  • Contact us
  • Investor Relations
  • News Room
  • Quality & Reliability
  • Sales & Distribution
  • Incubators
Languages
  • English
  • 简体中文
  • 日本語
Newsletter

Interested in the latest news and articles about ADI products, design tools, training and events? Subscribe today!

Sign Up
Analog Logo
©1995 - 2023 Analog Devices, Inc. All Rights Reserved
沪ICP备09046653号-1
  • Sitemap
  • Legal
  • Privacy & Security
  • Privacy Settings
EngineerZone Uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience in our community. For more information on cookies, please read our Privacy & Security Statement.