Post Go back to editing

KCC's Quizzes AQQ292 about weighing using 2-plates scale

1. First, the quote of the week: "Some people create their own storms and then get mad when it rains" - Unknown

                                             

 2. New challenge with AQQ292 about using a two-plates scale.

This is a kind proposal from a frequent participant: Herman Neufeld, Analog & Mixed Signals Specialist):

You are asked to design a two-dish scale that weighs amounts of a substance from 1 to 40 grams in integer amounts.

Hence your task is to determine:

  1. What is the minimum number counterweights you need?
  2. What are the weigh values of these counterweights?

These, in order to weigh this substance,

Good luck and try to be among the first ones!

P.S. Please forward such quizzes to friends and colleagues who want also to "relax" their brains...

Please share your answer to view other submitted answers
Parents
  • Use six weights: 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 13 gm.

  • Thanks  , but there is a solution with only 4 elements!

  • Yes, the four-counterweight ternary method is a better solution.  Congratulations to those who found it.

    There are solutions with even fewer counterweights:

    One-counterweight, model A:  The problem states that we are to weigh amounts of a substance.  Place a 1 gm counterweight on one side of the scale, and enough of the substance on the other side to balance the scale.  Remove the weighed amount and continue weighing 1 gm amounts, and count the weighings.

    One-counterweight, model B:  The problem asks us to design a two-dish scale, so we can design the scale with one fixed-length arm, and one adjustable-length arm.  Place a 1 gm counterweight on the adjustable side dish and adjust that arm length to balance the unknown mass on the other dish.  Read the mass from the arm position, similar to a locker room scale.  Design the dish and arm masses to be inconsequentially small in order to neutralize their effect on the reading.

    Zero-counterweight:  The puzzle picture shows individual, removable masses as our counterweights.  Design a scale with one adjustable-length arm which uses the masses of its dish and arm as its reference mass.  There are no as-shown counterweights in this solution.

    Negative-counterweight:  The puzzle asks for the minimum number of counterweights, which would be an infinitely negative number of them.  We can use helium balloons as negative counterweights by attaching them to the test side of the scale.  An infinite quantity of infinitely-small helium balloons would comprise the minimum number of counterweights.  Given the design challenge of infinity, let's settle for a very large number of teeny-tiny helium balloons.

Reply Children
No Data