Post Go back to editing

KCC' Quizzes AQQ270 about a difference amplifier challenge

1. Quote of the week: 

2. New challenge AQQ270 about a Difference Amplifier challenge (this is a proposal from our colleague

Martin Walker, Product Marketing Leader at ADI UK – warm thanks to him!):

Below is the classic difference amplifier circuit.

Questions:

 1. What is the Common Mode Rejection Ratio (CMRR) if we have perfectly matched resistors?  [Assume the amplifier’s CMRR is 120dB]

 2. What is the CMRR if the resistors have a tolerance of 0.1%?

 3. What is the CMRR if the resistors have a tolerance of 1%?

 4. What input resistance does V2 ‘see’?

 5. What input resistance does V1 ‘see’?

 6. If the difference amplifier was AC-coupled, what impact would this inequality in input impedance have?

Good luck!



removed inappropriate Quote
[edited by: GenevaCooper at 1:18 PM (GMT -4) on 20 Sep 2024]
Please share your answer to view other submitted answers
Parents
  • 1. CMRR is 120 dB (all resistors are exactly 1k, otherwise ideal opamp.).  120 = 20 log (Ad/Acm) implies Ad = 10^60 Acm;  Acm negligeable in front of Ad.

    3. With 1% resistor, I get a 1.5% max change for Ad  ( R1=1.01K, R2=R4=990 and R=1k), ( Acm still negligeable since it is opamp dependant).
    2. With  0.1% resistor, I get a 0.06% max change for Ad  (R1=999, R2=1001, R3=1000, R4=999).  I confess that  used a simulator to obtain those numbers. My simulation may be incorrect.

    4.  R3 + R4
    5.  R1+ R2   (again, confirmed with the simulator,  (V+in - Vout) / Ir1)

    6. Not sure about the question. I add a capacitor parallel to R2 or to R4 ?  And definitively, if the input is AC, the frequency would impact the amplification.

  • Hi vanderghast,

    Yes, using a simulator with the resistance as a parameter you adjust to take into account the tolerance can help.  I make 1.5% about 36dB and 0.06% about -64dB, again matching closely with the theoretical work on this.

    Bingo on Q4.

    On Q5, try the simulator with equal and opposite voltage sources.  You'll find that the effective resistance that V1 'sees' is less than 1k!  Take a look at the current through R1.  Is it what you expect it to be?

    On question 6 I was more thinking about capacitively coupling the inputs and what effect the different input resistances would have on the cut-off frequency. 

  • About Q5, with opposite input voltages, V-in - Vout  will also increase. The current through R1 is then such it is still matching (V-in - Vout) / 2000.

    Here is a snapshot. I hope it is still readable.

Reply Children